Over three years ago, Gov. Rod Blagojevich put pharmacists on notice by requiring that they make the morning-after pill (also known as "Plan B") available to patients regardless of their religious or political beliefs. Later that year, two pro-life pharmacists mounted a legal challenge to this "administrative rule," arguing that it violated their religious beliefs. The case has been working its way through the judicial system ever since.
First, a circuit court ruled in 2005 that the plaintiffs' “right of conscience” argument had no legal merit. In 2007, an appellate court upheld that ruling. The two pharmacists then took their case to the Illinois Supreme Court. But instead of rendering a decision today, the high court sent the the plaintiffs back to square one, as the Tribune reported:
The Supreme Court decided the plaintiffs had presented sufficient evidence of potential harm to warrant having their case heard in court. Also, it noted, the administrative rule was amended in the settlement of a separate lawsuit last year, providing grounds for a reconsideration of the case.
Now the matter will return to the Sangamon County Circuit Court. While pro-lifers attempted to spin the decision as "supporting" the plaintiffs, I spoke to Illinois Planned Parenthood policy director Pam Sutherland this afternoon and she was confident the rule would ultimately be upheld. Below is a portion of our conversation:











