PI Original Adam Doster Wednesday December 9th, 2009, 1:30pm

More Shimkus Idiocy: "Does EPA Propose We Stop Breathing?"

On Monday, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) issued a long-anticipated ruling
that greenhouse gases threaten public health and the environment.
Environmentalists have praised the decision, which will allow the
agency to finally place limits on carbon emissions ...

On Monday, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) issued a long-anticipated ruling that greenhouse gases threaten public health and the environment. Environmentalists have praised the decision, which will allow the agency to finally place limits on carbon emissions under the Clean Air Act if Congress fails to curb emissions. Not surprisingly, GOP Rep. John Shimkus -- a friend of the polluters if there ever was one -- isn't so thrilled about this development. The AP got him on record about the ruling this morning:

Shimkus noted that carbon dioxide is a natural result of breathing and asked, "Does EPA propose we stop breathing?"

This isn't the first time Shimkus has offered up this ridiculous argument. Back in May, the Republican said during congressional testimony that since humans breathe out carbon dioxide, it is "not a toxic emittant":

In March, he also attempted to argue that we shouldn't curb CO2 emissions because we'll be depriving the plants of "food":

Of course, no one is proposing that we rid the world of CO2 - an essential element of our ecosystem and very existence. The problem is that extreme amounts of the gas -- caused by the burning of fossil fuels -- are floating into the atmosphere, altering the planet's natural climate and putting us at risk of great environmental and economic destruction.

In short, the Obama administration doesn't want to regulate our breathing patterns. They want to regulate, at a minimal price to most Americans, how much pollution Shimkus' campaign contributors send out into the air and water.

Comments Login or register to post comments

The dubious congressman is putting more than his fair share of CO2 in the atmosphere. I suggest he cease and desist. While he is at it, leave office. The man is a menace and a nuisance proving it every time he opens his mouth to release more unwanted CO2.

Also, his constituents are wondering where he was during the president's speech at West Point last Fri. According to the congressman, he was supposed to attend. We have grandiloquence announcing the event. Afterwards?? No-Show Shimkus??

The MadCo Rumor Mill is all abuzz ---->> It seems that the congressman thought he was flying with Air Force One (NOT!!). When he learned that he had to fly up to New York commercial (egads!! -- not with us little people!!), on his dime, he decided to not attend. There has been silence on the subject of the West Point speech from the congressman since. Lots of other quality CO2, though.

ALISON, MPA
Philosophe Forum

Recent content

Thu
9.2.10
Wed
9.1.10
Tue
8.31.10
Mon
8.30.10