An ad circulating online could be one of the nastiest slams against
Barack Obama yet to surface. Run by the conservative National Campaign
Fund, it attempts to blame the one-time Illinois state senator -- who
supported Chicago's handgun ban and denounced the state's capital
punishment procedures -- for three 2001 Chicago murders. The ad then asks: "Can a man so weak in the war on gangs be trusted in the war on terror?" (Video after the jump.)
The allegation of causality in these ads is ludicrous, to say the least. For one, the evidence that capital punishment is a deterrent to violent crime is shaky at best. And in Illinois, the state's death penalty laws were notoriously fraught, which Obama himself helped reform while in the statehouse. Thirteen people were released from death row because evidence had turned up that proved they were innocent or that their convictions had been tainted, leading to a justifiable moratorium that still stands.
Secondly, Chicago's murder rate actually declined while Obama was in Springfield, dropping from 789 homicides per 100,000 residents in 1996 to 448 in 2004. Attributing the drop to Obama's legislative efforts doesn't tell the whole story, of course; but the policies he and his colleagues pushed certainly didn't hurt.
Of course, this ad wasn't designed to present a rigorous analytic argument. It was created by Floyd Brown, the man responsible for the reprehensible "Willie Horton" ad against Michael Dukakis in 1988. Every four years, Brown resurfaces to sling his cheap, fearmongering attacks while Republicans stand idly by, quietly denouncing the spots but declining to intervene with any ferocity. Salon's Joe Conason suggests that "McCain must tell the Republican faithful, including the high-rolling donors who may finance Brown's advertising, that he is a pariah -- and that anyone who underwrites that kind of campaign will be unwelcome in a McCain White House." After this past month, such a statement would be valuable, but doesn't seem likely.
You can read more about Brown and the Vast-Ring Wing Conspiracy to which he ascribes at Fight the Smears.
Here's the video of the ad:
Michael Ejercito (not verified) on Sat, 09/06/2008 - 19:54
Hale DeMar faced a life or death decision on December 28, 2003.
That night, the fifty-nine-year-old Wilmette, Illinois resident woke up to find a burglar attempting to break into his home. He had experienced a burglary not long before
As he explained in his letter to the Chicago Sun Times:
"For me, the seconds until I found my children still safely tucked in their beds were horrifying … The police were called and in routine fashion they came, took the report and with little concern left, promising to increase surveillance. Little comfort, since the invader now had keys to our home and our automobiles. The police informed me that this was not an uncommon event in east Wilmette and offered their condolences …"
DelMar confronted the criminal and shot him; the criminal subsequently fled.
While Cook County prosecutors determined that DelMar acted lawfully, the village of Wilmette prosecuted him for violating the handgun ban.
The people of Illinois were outraged. The Democratic-majority legislature passed a law that would allow people who use handguns to deter o defend against intruders into their homes to assert self-defense if prosecuted for violating local handgun bans; the House passed it by 86-25 and the Senate passed this by 38-20. Clearly, the Illinois legislature saw the plain need for change in Illinois's laws.
Senator Barack Obama voted against this law. This was change he did not believe in.
Post new comment